A New Model for Marketers: Observation, Participation, Co-Creation
TopRankVisibility Digital Marketing Agency

  • 04/11/2018
  • SMM
No Comments



For over 100 years, marketers have used this notion of managing the funnel. That is getting consumers to become aware, interested, have desire and have taken action, in fact, it was called the AIDA model and it’s been around since 1902 and it’s something that most marketers have used and many still do use but we don’t think that it really accurately reflects the way in which consumers move through this stage.

Loyalty loop

Loyalty loop

In fact, McKinsey in 2009 came out with their version that they called the Loyalty loop and it too basically reflected a consumer who moved through a kind of a linear process. But in their case, they said they would come back after purchase and buy again. We think both of these really have helped marketers over the years, but they don’t reflect the way it works now. So instead of us pushing out things and having people go through a linear process how does the world work today? So of course marketers are still and brands are still sending out messages. And if those messages happen to catch a customer who’s motivated. And they may go ahead and make a purchase, and if they make a purchase, then they’ll go ahead and own the product, and if they own the product, they’re either satisfied or they’re unsatisfied. Now, that will still happen, but the thing that is fundamentally changed is this customer engagement behavior. So that people are no longer waiting for messaging from brands, but rather they’re talking to each other. And that’s really the engagement that happens because of social media. Back in one, we learned that the consumer controls the marketplace. And that peer to peer recommendations are really big.

Let’s assume I’m looking on Facebook, checking my Facebook messages, and I see my friend has just gone out and bought a brand new Toyota Prius. She’s so happy about it, she’s posted a picture of herself right on Facebook. So, of course, I look at it, I comment, but I realize that this car that I used to think was ugly now looks really good.  It’s really nicely designed. And I think to myself well I might consider this car the next time I’m in the market. Well, I then go and post a message to her telling her that I’m happy about it and by the way where did she buy it?

Offline she lets me know I go and I look at some websites and then, of course, I’m now getting messages from marketers who are retargeting me because they know that I’ve gone and followed. Eventually, I go in and I might buy the car. I go ahead and I buy the car and what happens to me? I’m happy about it, I take a picture of myself, I post it on Facebook and now my friends know about it now when we look at that example.

Toyota Prius had nothing to do with alerting me, advertising to me. They didn’t even know that I was in the market. I didn’t even know that I was in the market. My friend is the advertiser. Because she was a satisfied customer. This is really the power of social media of course, as you know, but it’s also a reflection of the big change that the model doesn’t indicate. We’ve got friends, peers, even strangers propose customer reviews who are in most cases, as or more influential than an advertisement.

What is the new marketers model look like?

The new model is dynamic. It is constantly in motion. When any one of these five attributes, gears really in the engine. Anyone of them is moving, all the rest of them are moving. It moves the entire engine. So it might be a customer who’s happy with their new car, who’s talking about it. That changes their behavior which suddenly causes a motivation in a stranger, in my case me, to change which may result ultimately in a purchase. Where the brand has nothing to do with it. So it’s not linear, it’s dynamic, it’s constantly in motion.

Okay, so far my consumer point of view: What are the different levels of consumer engagement that you see out there? So we’ve done research and we’ve actually found that there are three levels of engagement and that those three levels of engagement actually correlate to customer value, which means the more actively and relevantly engaged you are, the more valuable you are to the company, you spend more money. And we found that over a number of different research efforts.

First stage of engagement

Let’s start with the first one. The first stage of engagement is just observation, some researchers call this, the advertising effect. I didn’t know about something and now suddenly I know about. But in the Prius example, I don’t know about it from Prius or Toyota, I know about it from my friends. So anything that has to do with an observation. Observing a post, observing a video. A friend sends something to me, I read it. An email that’s about a brand, those are all observing. And we found that people who in fact, observe about a brand are more valuable than those that don’t.

Second stage of engagement

However, they are not nearly as valuable as those who are actively participating. Participating is where I’m doing more than just reading or watching, but I’m actually sharing myself, I’m posting, I’m tweeting. I’m retweeting, I’m sharing with other people and that level of participation ends up being more than twice as valuable the companies as just observing.So we’ve got the people that are observing and moving to action, but if I get people to actually engage, they are twice as valuable?

Third stage of engagement

And there are people who are even valuable than them and those are the ones. That is active, what we call, co-creating with the brand. So co-creation is where customers are so actively engaged with the brand that they actually produce new products and services. So, great example Frito Lay has a contest that they’ve run where they invite their loyal customers to recommend new flavors. And so the way they do it is, they ask them to go ahead and produce a video, put it up on YouTube, and let the world vote on whether or not they are compelled to agree that this particular person’s belief in a new flavor is the one that Frito Lay ought to go out and create. And in fact, winning flavor by virtue of votes from other fans is actually created as a new Frito Lay product. So the people that have actually gone and produced a video think about the incredible passion that they feel about this brand that they’re going to spend their time doing things.

And we’ve found from our research that it’s the co-creators that are exponentially more valuable than the ones who are just participating.


Do you want to implement great Social Media Marketing for your business?

Have you ever asked yourself this question: When it comes to online marketing, why do some people succeed while others are left spinning their wheels? While you may be great in sales, your website isn’t. Despite the fact that website looks really good, rarely does it bring in any leads or actual sales. Over the years I’ve noticed a pattern: successful marketers use a very specific system to achieve nearly exponential growth. And it is the Online Sales Funnel (a.k.a. lead generation funnel, relationship funnel, customer value optimization funnel or marketing funnel). We work in areas as diverse as Inbound Marketing, Affiliate Marketing, Search Engine Optimization, Social Media Marketing, Email Marketing, Pay-Per-Click Marketing, Content Marketing, Marketing Automation, SEO friendly Web Design.

 About us and this blog

We are a digital marketing company with a focus on helping our customers achieve great results across several key areas.

Request a free quote

We offer professional SEO services that help websites increase their organic search score drastically in order to compete for the highest rankings even when it comes to highly competitive keywords.

Subscribe to our newsletter and Get FREE eBook "THE ULTIMATE GUIDE TO CONTENT MARKETING!"

Fields marked with an * are required
Website and Marketing Packages
Let's make your online business successful
Do you want to be successful online?
We've been marketing and building websites since 1994 and this experience grows and matures as we do. We have come up with a range of website packages that will allow most businesses to:
  1. Have a great looking Website
  2. Have a website designed to actually work
  3. Have a website that is SEO friendly
  4. Have a website designed to market your business
  5. Have a website that attracts your target customers
  6. Have a website that works with Social Media to generate prospects
  7. Comes complete with a comprehensive marketing package

More from our blog

See all posts